EU failing to enforce illegal fishing rules, say campaigners
Or Fish One Is Of The Every Unreported Through In Five File Illegal Around Fishing Picture: Biggest Causes Fishing Is Unregulated Damien One Overfishing Illegal, World: Of Eagers The Caught
Campaigners have said the EU is failing to enforce rules on illegal fishing, and allowing member states to conceal information that could help uncover breaches of fishing law.
The court of justice of the EU ruled on Thursday that member states could keep vital details of their implementation of fishing rules under wraps, in a blow to environmental campaigners hoping to use the information to show whether the regulations are working.
There are suspicions many fishing vessels are flouting restrictions meant to protect fish populations in the EU’s seas, by under-reporting their catches or by discarding fish at sea. But member states are often reluctant to enforce the rules stringently, under pressure from their fishing industries.
The campaigning organisation ClientEarth brought a legal case against the European Commission contesting its refusal to grant access to audit reports for France and Denmark, which would show whether those governments were controlling illegal fishing properly.
But the EU court found, in an appeal judgment, that the audit reports could remain secret, which campaigners said made a mockery of the rules.
Anne Friel, a senior lawyer at ClientEarth, said: “People and NGOs are being deprived of their very basic rights — knowing whether member states are actually complying with the laws that exist to protect them and the environment, and what the commission is doing about it.
Illegal fishing is one of the biggest causes of overfishing around the world: one in every five fish is caught through illegal, unreported or unregulated fishing. Many countries have rules on reporting catches, and where and how fish can be caught, but the difficulty of monitoring vessels’ activities on the high seas, and an unwillingness to take on fishing lobbies, have hampered efforts to stamp out harmful practices.
The European Commission was intending to take legal action against member states that failed to enforce its ban on the wasteful practice of discarding fish at sea, but scrapped that action without a clear explanation.
Thursday’s appeal judgment marks the final stage of the attempt to gain transparency over the fishing audit reports, after ClientEarth’s case — first brought in 2021 — was first thrown out by judges last year.