Letters to the Editor: Sarah Harte's column about Gaza was both heartening and heartbreaking 

Letter-writers consider issues including human rights, neutrality, and plans for cycling infrastructure — and one reader is inspired by Tom Dunne to recall a classic gig when U2 played support to Slade 
Letters to the Editor: Sarah Harte's column about Gaza was both heartening and heartbreaking 

Larry Solidarity By Cork The Cork Cummins Palestine Protest February City Through Saturday 10 Campaign Picture: Organised On March 18th Centre The

It was both heartening and heartbreaking to read Sarah Harte’s description of the protests organised by the Cork Palestine Solidarity Campaign — ‘Ministers must speak out against war on Gaza while visiting the US’ (Irish Examiner, February 7).

Heartening because it gives hope to see the empathy and depth of feeling on the streets of Ireland for the beleaguered people of Palestine. The anti-war demonstration mentioned was the seventeenth march through the city of Cork in solidarity with Gaza since the slaughter began last October. What a tremendous effort by the extraordinary people of Cork. Well done to everybody who has turned up to make their voices heard. They make me proud to be from Cork.

It was heartbreaking, of course, because the horrific destruction and mass killing still goes on. Among the dead are thousands of children — babies, kids, teenagers — and the people of Gaza are now exposed to hunger and a shortage of medical supplies as well as the bombs and bullets from Israeli forces. To add to their misery, several countries — including the US and Britain — have suspended funding to UNRWA, the most important United Nations humanitarian organisation on the ground, because of unsubstantiated allegations by Israel against a handful of low-level employees. And this at a time of unimaginable need.

As Ms Harte argues, our politicians must listen to the people on the streets and should “speak up loudly and unambiguously” to say “we do not support the mass killing of children and that Joe Biden should call for a ceasefire”. 

Our politicians surely recognise that the US is a co-partner of Israel in this war — and it cannot escape culpability for what is happening. In my view, the visit to the White House should be cancelled.

Fintan Lane, Lucan, Co Dublin

Human rights are being undermined

Referencing the loss of life of non-combatants in Gaza, a terrible nadir of human concern, President Michael D Higgins highlighted last week the very real risk posed by this conflict to the discourse of international human rights and humanitarian law.

Ongoing complex conflicts are increasingly protracted, leaving civilians without protection, hungry, displaced, and dependent on dwindling humanitarian assistance.

For example, the Sudan conflict has resulted in the displacement of 7.4m people, with 17.7m (37% of the population) experiencing acute food insecurity.

In Ukraine, Yemen, Haiti, and across the Sahel — Niger, Mali, Burkina Faso — peace remains elusive and humanitarian needs grow.

Concern is responding, wherever and however we can, to reach communities devastated by months of relentless fighting.

The responsibility to uphold international human rights and humanitarian law is shared by all countries. However the permanent members of the UN Security Council are vested with particular authority. Their adherence to and respect for human rights is critical in setting the tone.

The world cannot afford to normalise the suffering of innocent civilians. Nor can the world afford to further undermine international humanitarian and human rights law.

David Regan, CEO, Concern Worldwide, 52-55 Camden St, Dublin 2

Loss of neutrality

You report that a British think tank has berated Ireland for “freeloading” with regard to defence and security — ‘Ireland accused of ‘freeloading’ off defence investment of others’ (Irish Examiner, online February 4).

The Policy Exchange paper on Ireland’s defence arrangements is hard to stomach for those committed to maintaining Ireland’s neutrality, but its unrestrained analysis of Ireland’s security policy is not unwelcome in that it confirms much of what the defenders of neutrality have long claimed — that the government is inching its way towards Nato membership.

For instance, the report states that Ireland “joined Nato’s Operational Capability Concept (OCC) in 2016, whose goal is to assist non-members in reaching Nato standards, and to foster interoperability. Part of the alliance’s PfP programme, the OCC offers training and evaluations of force capabilities across the domain spectrum, helping them — at least in theory — to meet the standards necessary for future membership.”

The report blurts out a number of other things normally kept hush-hush in Irish establishment circles. Most informative of all — in the section titled “Exert greater pressure on Ireland to do its part in collective security” — is the following statement: “The last few years have shown that some political and social circles in Ireland now understand the important role they must play in their partners’ security. There is therefore no longer any excuse for Ireland not to do its upmost to expedite its military and security development.” Ah, but there is: the majority of people in Ireland do not want what the hawks of Policy Exchange are demanding of us. 

I would venture to suggest, too, that the report’s hectoring — one might even describe it as “imperious” — tone may irk many who read it. Except, of course, those in the “political and social circles in Ireland” that Policy Exchange senses are open to its influence.

Dominic Carroll, Ardfield, Cork

Weak defences

The first duty of any government is to defend its people. The Government is not in that position. 

The Defence Forces are not capable of withstanding a probe not to mention an attack. We have relied on the RAF, and English and French navies to provide cover for too long. Our Defence Forces chiefs have again pointed out this glaring weakness. Irish security has been and is under threat. No self respecting republic can continue to rely on our neighbours to provide that cover. 

In defending ourselves we are also defending Europe. The Government must move to ensure Irish security.

Leonard Hurley, Caherciveen, Co Kerry

Mahon cycle plans

Regarding the article — ‘Furious residents worried about scale of tree-felling in Cork’s first neighbourhood cycle scheme’ (Irish Examiner, online, February 6): This project is a complete waste of public money. 

There is no need to be digging up footpaths — 90% of which are perfectly fine. The roads around Mahon are wide enough to accommodate cyclists and motorists — also the trees they plan to remove are young, strong, healthy ones that provide shelter and homes for local wildlife. To remove parking from outside people’s homes is a joke; some people will have to park a five to
10-minute walk from their homes. There will be no parking outside local schools, shops, and sports clubs. There is provision for 30 car parking spaces between Ringmahon Rangers pitch and the rugby pitches to be shared when grounds are in use. On any given match day or evening there’s at least 100 to 300 cars outside these sports clubs. 

As a member of one of these clubs, I can reveal that we got no notification about the works or the removal of parking outside our grounds. Since works have started traffic management and health and safety issues around the area are none existent

Tim Murphy, Mahon, Cork

Pause Mahon work

As a resident of Mahon I have major concern of access to my park. I have no major issue with the concept of bicycle lanes but when parking spaces are being eliminated and trees are being cut to make room for the lanes there must be a pause to reflect on what is being done. 

A prime example is Ringmahon soccer pitch: on match day both sides of Ringmahon road are used for parking but this will no longer apply with bicycle lanes. This flow of traffic will filter into surrounding parks and create issues for residents trying to exit their homes. 

The planners need to take a look of the overall plan urgently and pause current work.

Paul Barry, Mahon, Cork 

Community benefit

Many of those who are outraged about the Mahon cycle scheme are being misled by Facebook posts and hearsay. 

They hear “cutting down our trees” and “no parking” and instantly, and rightfully, get angry. When they witness immaculate new pavements, safer cycle routes for the local kids, and see how safer and cleaner their community is, I believe many of them will realise that their anger was misplaced. Some say there are no cyclists and the lanes will not be used. 

I think when we have the good weather for it we will see them being used plenty. The cycle lanes will also encourage people to use them.

Kieran O’Sullivan, Mahon

Best U2 gig ever

Slade (‘Come and feel the noise with Slade' — Irish Examiner, January 1) reminds me of the best U2 gig I ever attended.

I had travelled to London for a weekend of gigs, including a concert by Slade in mid October, 1980, at The Lyceum. 

Standing in the queue, word filtered back that one of the two support bands had pulled out, and a band called U2 was taking their place. 

For a blasé London attendee, it mattered not, but I was ecstatic. 

Having seen them many times in Ireland, I decided to take a different approach on the night. I sat in the balcony to observe the crowd. The first support band came and went, leaving behind an empty floor. Then U2 started their 30-minute slot before an empty floor. 

But, with classics like ‘11 O’Clock Tick Tock’ and more, they lured the cynical crowd onto the floor and, at the end of their set, they had the place rocking. 

U2 had arrived — everywhere. And Slade were good as well.

Tadhg Ó Cruadhlaoich, via email

   

More in this section

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

Limited Group Examiner © Echo