Letters to the Editor: Fearless but gentle, Ivor Browne helped many people through turmoil

A number of correspondents celebrate the life of the late Ivor Browne, while others consider issues including sustainable agriculture, mental health, and the Middle East crisis
Letters to the Editor: Fearless but gentle, Ivor Browne helped many people through turmoil

Brown Cummins Picture: Nash, In Larry Right, Taking Music Eoin At Of In Ivor Cork Public Cit School June And 2016 A Interview Author With Psychiatrist Part

Fearless, yet gentle in disposition. Idiosyncratic, yet so generously accommodating. Creatively astute, yet all the while developing persuasive templates for human wellbeing in the round.

Prof Ivor Browne was a once-in-a-generation human being of supreme, yet underrated, worth to the nation — often marginalised and crassly ignored by many of his clinical peers.

He was a truly humane presence within the flux and flow of societal change and challenge, a proud and protracted purveyor of creative holism in the most worthy sense.

He helped so many people to manage personal psychological turmoil — as he bravely challenged the status quo notions of wellbeing and responses to life distress — frequently enduring derision and ridicule from many of his peers, from a self-protective psychiatric system trapped within big pharma’s tentacles.

His broad-spectrum visionary awareness and explorations of the human psyche were — in many ways — simple, yet profoundly compelling.

CLIMATE & SUSTAINABILITY HUB

A music man through and through, Ivor wallowed in the ether of “melodic magic”.

He was an enthusiastic supporter of clinical music therapy when others demurred and declined.

Often, Ivor’s penchant for taking a road less travelled attracted a sceptical mistrust of his bona fide professional kudos — whereas it really afforded him a credible entrée to the authentic world of those distressed, away from the claustrophobic jargon of diagnostic labelling.

Meeting Ivor was an uplifting experience for sure — disarming and charming in equal measure.

His candid honesty was arresting, but never oppressive, and while he may have revelled in self-profiling and never shy of media coverage — one has to forgive such minor foibles in light of his seminal achievements, influential writings and, of course, his many clinical successes.

He was accommodating to me as a clinical professional and representative, and it was a pleasurable privilege to have known him — albeit on a sporadic basis.

There won’t be his like again.

Something of the fragile thread of clinical empathic essence has been lost with Ivor’s passing, but hopefully his free-spirited curiosity and innate inclusivity will survive and thrive to inspire “in posterum cum gaudio”.

Jim Cosgrove, Lismore, Co Waterford

Ivor Browne helped me out of a crisis

I was sad to hear of the death of Prof Ivor Browne.

While my dealings with him were professional, I looked on him as more of a friend than a psychiatrist.

I was in crisis when I first met him in 1993. I was on lithium, which psychiatrists in Galway had prescribed for me, but it was in fact doing very little — if anything — for my severe bouts of depression and suicidal thoughts.

Prof Browne proposed to take me off the lithium and undergo a regression therapy called holotropic breathwork, which he had been using with clients in a former church in St Brendan’s Hospital, in Grangegorman.

I benefited from this at the time and later, in recent years, I went back to this form of therapy.

I had setbacks along the way, setbacks which tended to trigger my suicidal thoughts. After he retired from St Brendan’s Hospital in 1995, and I was referred to other therapists, I went back to him I think four times in the next 20 years — three of these times I was in crisis.

I have often wondered what would have happened to me if I had never met him.

Would I have come off medication on my own, without the support of a professional? Would I have come across holotropic breathwork some other way? ho would I have turned to at times of crisis along the way?

I’ll never know the answers to these questions, but there is no doubt in my mind that if I had remained within the conventional psychiatric system of medication I would not have gotten through.

For this, I owe Prof Browne an enormous amount of gratitude.

Ar dheis Dé go raibh a anam uasal.

Tommy Roddy, Ballybane, Galway

Fund farmers to explore varied crops over meat

Ireland needs to start reducing its intensive beef and dairy production, and start promoting eating less meat and keeping meat as a treat.

Instead, more plant-based meals should be put in the fore.

Ireland should start funding farmers to produce more pulses and incentivise exploring more varied crops.

Animal rearing should be centred around small herds of native, well-adapted breeds — which graze in order to maintain biodiversity and meadows.

Ireland can’t continue to export beef as “sustainable” and greenwash grass-fed as low carbon.

L Ramsay, Dublin

Deaths are a wake-up call for those seeking Mental Heath Act reform

The shocking killings of Grace O’Malley-Kumar, Barnaby Webber, and Ian Coates in Nottingham last year, by Valdo Calocane — a man suffering from paranoid schizophrenia — is a wake-up call for those advocates who are calling for the reform of our Mental Health Act, so as to raise the threshold for detention for those suffering from mental illness and refusing treatment.

This will mean mental health professionals will have to wait until a patient is severely ill before they can intervene, and must release the patient from detention as soon as they are showing signs of recovery.

It is time that the views of mental health professionals at the front line of care are listened to, above those well-meaning advocates who have little appreciation of the consequences for families when a loved one relapses and becomes paranoid about them and others.

Frank Browne, Templeogue, Dublin 16

Tánaiste needs to do a lot more on Gaza

Foreign Affairs Minister Micheál Martin needs to do far more about Israel’s decimation of Gaza than ask the EU to issue travel bans against violent Israeli settlers in the West Bank (‘Tánaiste to push for the introduction of EU-wide sanctions against Israel’, January 20).

How many of them does he think are planning trips to the EU?

And what action does he propose the EU take against the Israeli Defence Forces for killing 360 Palestinians, in the occupied West Bank, since October 7?

Mr Martin must seek EU sanctions against Israel — the entire country, not just a handful of settlers.

And while the EU procrastinates, the Irish Government should impose its own trade ban on Israel.

Ask the people of this country what they want the Government to do about Israel’s war against the people of Gaza, and I am certain the great majority will agree with the imposition of hard-hitting measures.

Mr Martin’s proposed half-measure won’t do.

Dominic Carroll, Ardfield, Co Cork

Fearless Norris is who we should aspire to be

As David Norris departs from public political activities, I simply wish to say — on all fronts — Mr Norris, you are what we should all aspire to be: Fearless, courageous, with plenty of pluck and a thick shin, and refusing to put up with the nay-sayers and people who — for some reason — seem reluctant to stand for any real social change being achieved for the benefit of all.

Thankfully, the nation is — for better or worse — more enlightened on many issues which, in days gone by, were taboo.

Fresh air always clears the air and closed minds never, in the final analysis, succeed.

You have done your bit (and more) to drag the slow followers into reality over the past three decades.

More to do, but the road ahead — at least thanks to you and others — is optimistic. Enjoy your rest.

Kevin McCarthy, Gouldavoher, Co Limerick

More in this section

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

Limited Echo © Group Examiner