IMAGES
VIDEO
AUDIO
An investigative series by Irish Examiner journalist
Ann Murphy
From florist to fraudster, leaving a trail of destruction from North Cork, to Waterford, to Clare, to Wexford and through the midlands ... learn how mistress of re-invention, Catherine O'Brien, scammed her way around rural Ireland.
Listen to the podcasts
Extra content
EPISODES
2
3
4
Q&A
5
6
A Mistress of Re-Invention
As life goes on as normal in busy Ballinroad in Dungarvan, Co Waterford, one of the area’s most interesting characters is no longer part of the daily grind. Catherine O’Brien is now a wanted woman, with gardai and people who believe they were conned by her trying to find her.
As life goes on as normal in busy Ballinroad in Dungarvan, Co Waterford, one of the area’s most interesting characters is no longer part of the daily grind. Catherine O’Brien is now a wanted woman, with gardai and people who believe they were conned by her trying to find her.
Neighbours tell of people turning up at her door to find her, while victims tell stories of how the trust she earned from them was abused.
So who is Catherine O’Brien and why do gardai want to talk to her? Listen to find out how the one-time florist got involved in the pub trade, the veterinary business and the horse industry, while persuading new friends that she was an expert in legal matters. She was a business woman with connections including a link to the Vatican. She drove only the best vehicles.
But Catherine the Fake tells a tale of someone who leaves a trail of destruction in her wake. See how she grabbed the attention of the Criminal Assets Bureau and hear how she is remembered as being as slippery as an eel, managing to evade law enforcement as well as those who were once close to her.
...Read more
EPISODES
1
3
4
Q&A
5
6
Gold Digging on Waterford’s Copper Coast
A member of west Waterford’s Ango Irish ascendancy, Nicola Beresford Minihan, lost her home and another property due to the machinations of Catherine O’Brien, the woman she believed was like a daughter to her.
As Nicola tells her story, immerse yourself in how her life evolved from growing up in the sprawling Woodhouse estate on the outskirts of coastal Stradbally to living her later years in rented accommodation, thanks to her friendship and business forays with Catherine. See how their relationship developed from Nicola’s role as child minder to one of Catherine’s children, to becoming a director in some of her businesses, to mortgaging her home to help her build up a business.
Discover too the kindnesses that were scattered here and there. There was the fairytale holiday which still brings a smile to Nicola’s face despite the pain and hardships that resulted from meeting the chameleon that is Catherine O’Brien.
But through it all, the one question on Nicola’s lips is why nobody told her of the danger of getting involved with Catherine O’Brien.
...Read more
EPISODES
1
2
4
Q&A
5
6
It's a long way from Clare to here
Catherine O’Brien was not only a financial fraudster but also a romance fraudster. Find out how she conned her lover out of €20,000 and tried to ensure his family signed a contract which asked that they would not “conduct any drive bys” of his house while she was there.
Despite a relationship which appeared to be blossoming, this was one built on suspicion, suspense and intrigue and did not promise a happy-ever-after. But it brought a new playground for Catherine, with new friends to impress and new people to inveigle into business plans, with her focus switching from floristry to veterinary thanks to her new connections in Co Clare.
She told her newfound friends of having bought a pub in west Clare, and advertised positions for the venue – but the jobs did not exist because she had not made the purchase. However, she had prestige as a business woman who had a home in Dungarvan and connections which secured corporate boxes in Croke Park. She was someone who appeared to have it all.
But did she have it all? Who was this woman who had infiltrated the social scene in west Clare and earned the trust of people who later regretted having met her?
...Read more
EPISODES
1
2
3
Q&A
5
6
Horses for courses
Catherine O’Brien became a well-known figure in Ireland’s horsey set and Senator David Norris was almost woven into her ever-expanding web after she turned to him for advice.
She is someone different to everyone she meets, in her bid to earn people’s trust, as a live investigation is underway into frauds she is suspected of carrying out in equine circles.
Discover how she dodges those looking for her, and how innocent people who never met or heard of Catherine O’Brien find themselves fielding queries on how to locate her. See how her love for horses led to her downfall, with more than 30 animals in her care found in shocking states of emaciation, resulting in a bench warrant being issued for her arrest.
As the animals remain in a horse shelter, the search for Catherine O’Brien continues and that bench warrant remains live. And as the hunt goes on, the stories of her escapades continue to emerge.
...Read more
EPISODES
1
2
3
4
5
6
Your Questions Answered
Florist turned fraudster, Catherine O'Brien, has left a trail of destruction in her wake. And now she is being hunted by Gardaí.
Irish Examiner journalist, Ann Murphy, has been working on this story for many months now. Listeners to the podcasts have come back with a lot of questions about how we came across this story, how we investigated it, and some of the details that haven't been published in the podcasts to date.
This Q&A with Ann Murphy and Irish Examiner news editor, Deirdre O'Shaughnessy, answers your questions.
...Read more
EPISODES
1
2
3
4
Q&A
6
When In Rome
Few though can expect to have a private audience with the Pope of the time – but alleged fraudster Catherine O’Brien is among those few.
Marie O’Shea from Stradbally in west Waterford was invited to travel to the Vatican with Catherine for a meeting with the Pope.
Accompanying Catherine on the visit was a sign of how close the two women had become in the four years since Marie had first met her socially, during a visit to Catherine’s home with mutual friend Nicola Minihan.
The visit was “an incredible uplifting experience for Marie” as it came after a very tough time for her. She was given the best news she could have hoped for before embarking on the trip to Rome with Catherine – that a tumour which her medical team had been fighting had shrunk and she was in remission after being diagnosed in 2005 with cancer.
Catherine O’Brien borrowed large sums of money from Marie O’Shea. On June 17, 2009, a court order against Catherine ordered that she pay a total of €289,194.47 to Marie – a sum which included what she had borrowed from Marie, as well as interest, costs and expenses. However, by the time of Marie’s death in January 2016, the money still had not been paid.
...Read more
EPISODES
1
2
3
4
Q&A
5
Tall Tales in Tipperary
Knocklofty House near Clonmel is a 17-bedroom sprawling building nestled into an impressive estate 9kms west of Clonmel. In 1994, Tipperary native Denis English bought the property and he also owned the nearby Marlfield House.
Marlfield House, where Denis still lives, is also a very historic property. It was the home of the Bagwell family between the 18th and 20th centuries.
The family were influential in Irish Unionist society and the property was built in 1785.
Both properties are household names way beyond Clonmel – and both caught the attention of Catherine O’Brien, after it emerged that Denis English was in financial difficulties. These difficulties received press coverage, including coverage of attempts to sell the properties.
It is where Denis sits down to recall how he thought the answer to his financial woes could be found when a lifeline was dangled before him by none other than Catherine O’Brien. A woman he had never met until then but who promised him a way out of the financial doldrums he was in. She convinced the desperate property owners she was in the pay of a Saudi sheikh who could solve all their money worries.
...Read more
icon She is like an eel – nobody can catch her.
Catherine O'Brien is originally from Boherascrub in Buttevant, north Cork. This is the most up-to-date image we have of her from 2021 - supplied by Irish Mail on Sunday.
Catherine has been living for many years in Dungarvan, Co. Waterford. This detached house at An Ghrianan in Ballinroad is her home there. The house has been lying empty for several months.
Catherine's whereabouts are unknown at present. Many people are looking for Ms. O'Brien because she owes them money. The Gardaí are also looking for her ... there is a bench warrant out for her arrest following an animal cruelty conviction in 2021 in her absence.
Catherine was convicted of more than thirty counts of animal welfare breaches in relation to horses that were seized in Ballygarret in Co. Wexford the previous year in 2020.
Catherine, who has two grown up daughters, also failed to turn up in court in February 2022 for a Proceeds of Crime hearing in the High Court in Dublin. A decision was made in favour of the Criminal Assets Bureau, allowing the retention by the State of a 2015-registered Land Rover Discovery.
icon I think that is what kills me more. Somebody I considered a friend could do that to me.
Nicola Beresford Minihan, who came to know Catherine O'Brien through a relative of hers, became involved in business with her in Stradbally, Co. Waterford.
Nicola mortgaged two of her houses to help Catherine O'Brien to set up in business and subsequently lost her houses to the bank. Pictured is Stradbally House where Nicola lived when she met Catherine.
Nicola comes from an aristrocratic background in west Waterford. Stradbally is the location of the Woodhouse Estate, where Nicola grew up.
Nicola sold some pieces of furniture which had been in her family. But she has held on to the piano she played as a child in Woodhouse in Stradbally, which her father, Lord William Mostyn de la Poer Beresford, had inherited.
Catherine set up a number of floristry businesses including Stradbally Garden Centre and Celtic Landscapes in Stradbally. As company documents show, this was set up in January of 2003.
Nicola Beresford Minihan and Catherine O'Brien were both listed as Directors of the Stradbally flower shop. Nicola’s home at that point - was also used as the registered office for the company.
icon The affidavits of Catherine O’Brien contain explanations which are inherently improbable.
Mr Justice Alexander Owens delivered the judgement in the case relating to the 2015 registered Land Rover Discovery.
icon She has an uncanny way of sucking you in
Mr Paddy O’Donoghue, who runs a veterinary supplies business in Clare, supplied Catherine O'Brien with items for a veterinary supplies business she was setting up in Waterford. Paddy is still waiting for payment.
icon I used to meet her and she used to talk a big game about what she was doing. She was very persuasive, very charming.
PADDY O'DONOGHUE
icon She said she gets paid — the agent fella just sends over the money to pay everything.”
Beleaguered property owner Denis English was in trouble with the banks and in danger of losing his period mansions, Marlfield House and Knocklofty House. Both are historic properties worth a lot of money.
Promising a lifelong right of residency, unlimited holidays in the Middle East and a helicopter ride to the Galway races, Catherine O'Brien posed as the agent of an 'Arab prince' who could solve all Denis's problems.
iconWe were all here early to see the helicopter coming and then he got the phone call about her mother falling down the stairs. From then on, we got a bit suspicious that it [the deal] wasn’t going to happen.
As well as solidifying Denis’s future, his friend and employee Tom Moran was also to be retained at Marlfield under the new owners. Denis was to be Tom’s boss.
Read the story of how how mistress of re-invention, Catherine O'Brien, scammed her way around rural Ireland.
Read the articles hereSitting in her current home, Nicola Beresford Minihan recalls her association with Catherine O’Brien as being almost familial, describing herself as having been almost like a second mother to Catherine. But the bond she thought she shared with the Cork woman was shattered when the trust she put in her was abused as she wonders now what was real about anything Catherine had told her.
Scroll down for more video...
Catherine O'Brien 'was top class', says businessman who had narrow escape from fraudster, Catherine O'Brien.
Owner of Knocklofty House and Marlfield House in Co Tipperary, Denis English, was targeted by Catherine O'Brien, who promised him a way out of his financial difficulties.
Denis O'Regan’s friend and employee Tom Moran was also caught up in the deal with Catherine O'Brien. As part of the agreement of the sale of the Knocklofty and Marlfield houses to an Arabian royal, Tom was to be retained at the house under the new owners. Denis was to be Tom’s boss.
Catherine O'Brien appears to be arguing with an individual in this video. She was being secretly fimed on a smartphone. Video supplied.
Read the story of how how mistress of re-invention, Catherine O'Brien, scammed her way around rural Ireland.
Read the articles hereicon For sure and certain, she knew what she was doing
Paddy O'Donoghue owns a veterinary supply company in Co. Clare. He met Catherine O'Brien through an acquaintance and agreed to supply goods to Catherine for her to set up a Veterinary supply business in Dungarvan. He is still waiting to get paid for his goods.
icon A third of our capacity is taking up with horses that have been there since 2019.
Chief executive of the Irish Horse Welfare Trust, Sharon Power, says more than €250,000 has been spent on caring for the seized thoroughbred animals in the past three years.
Read the story of how how mistress of re-invention, Catherine O'Brien, scammed her way around rural Ireland.
Read the articles here